Yesterday I went to Target, and although I have about 30 jars of nut butter in my house already (literally there is a “Nut Butter” Spot in my closet), something drew me to this peanut butter. Creamy Cinnamon Peanut Butter by Archer’s Farms. I have been drawn to this peanut butter before, but never actually bought it until yesterday.
I was so excited to try it, the second I got home I took off the lid and gave it a stir. It was very runny, even after stirring it didn’t thicken up much. I thought about refrigerating it, but it said it capitals on the back “DO NOT REFRIGERATE”. So, I didn’t want anything weird to happen, so I listened. Nooooo refrigeration for this peanut butter!
Anyway-
I tasted it, and was slightly taken aback. I was expecting a cinnamon-sugar tasting peanut butter. Like a sweet peanut butter with a cinnamon after taste. Nope. THis was the type of cinnamon that was in those red cinnamon candies. Almost like a slightly spicy cinnamon. It was so bizarre.
While I can’t say I hated it, I also can’t really picture eating it out of the jar like I would with my other nut butters. Perhaps I’ll try it out on toast and see how it goes.
Until then, 3 stars. Not super excited about the taste or texture for that matter, too runny, but it was a very creamy peanut butter. Only 3 ingredients and all natural too!
*What’s your FAVORITE cinnamon-flavored thing?
2 tbsp (32 grams) is 180 calories, 14 grams of fat, 9 grams of carbohydrates, 3 grams of fiber 5 grams of sugar and 7 grams of protein.
Roasted Peanuts, Sugar, Cinnamon Oil.
I’m curious how my Greedy Kids would like this. As for my favorite cinnaminny-ness. Cinnamon Toast Bread! But gosh, it’s been ages.
oh mannn, cinnamon+sugar+butter on toast… best toast combination everr 🙂
I’m disappointed that this wasn’t that great!!! I LOVE pb and LOVE cinnamon, so I was hoping it would be awesome. Thanks for the review!
Thanks for saving me from buying this. I LOVE cinnamon and pb and have thought about buying that pb many times but then I think about all the nut butters I’ve tried over the yrs and there are only a few I really like so passed on this. something about it just didnt seem like it was going to be great – thanks for confirming it!